The Reality Concerning Structured Settlement Loans
July 30, 2014

If you look past all the marketing hype, I believe that you will also see that this new structured settlement loan product appears to be little more than a modified factoring transaction.  I suspect that the main feature that differentiates this so-called loan from the status quo is some provision in the transfer agreement that allows the annuitant to repay the bank prior to maturity, restoring the remaining portion of the factored structured settlement used as collateral and payment for the loan.  An early repayment option sounds compelling and revolutionary; however, experience tells me it’s all just window dressing, whereby, the reality is that very few to none will exercise this option.  I say this because in my twelve years as a factoring broker, I have worked with hundreds of annuitants and not done a single transaction with one annuitant that I believe would have had the will, resources or ability to repay one of these loans.    

Another concern is that they glossed over the fact that this transaction will probably be an expensive and time consuming undertaking, even if it can technically be called a loan.  Legal fees, insurer transfer fees, and court costs add up to thousands, not to mention any additional bank origination fees.  That’s why I always counsel credit worthy annuitants with more liquid collateral to first look to conventional funding sources for short term loans due to the transaction cost savings.  That leaves those with few other means to consider these new factoring-backed loans as a viable liquidity option.  The irony is that these same annuitants likely have little ability to repay any loans taken out on their structured settlements. It follows that all these loans become nothing more than standard factoring transactions if nobody exercises the early payment option and the factored annuity covers the loan obligations until maturity.

The reality is that there is no real disadvantage to a traditional factoring transaction when done correctly by an experienced and reputable firm.  The vast majority of our clients are just trying to keep their heads above water and I just can’t see any being interested in more loan debt.  Our policy is to work with annuitants to gain just enough liquidity from their structured settlements to pay their obligations and move forward, not lending them money that they likely can’t repay.  

SHARE ARTICLE

Our Recent Blogs

Bentzen Financial logo
November 18, 2026
Structured settlement recipients describe harassment in 2026, from calls that mimic local numbers to repeated texts and pressure on family members.
October 22, 2026
Back in May, John Oliver closed his segment by proposing that a one-time independent guardian or advisor review every sale before it happens, and a handful of states already appoint ad litems to do something close to it. On paper it's hard to argue with: a court-appointed advisor canvasses the market and makes sure the annuitant walks away with the highest offer on the table. We'd love to tell you it works. In practice, it too often produces the opposite of what it promises. Here's what actually happens when an ad litem "shops the market." The ad litem, who as a rule knows the courtroom far better than they know factoring or finance, solicits competing bids and takes the best one. But the market they think they're canvassing isn't the market that exists. Big players, such as those with a family of companies, operate under enough names that a fistful of "competing" offers can all trace back to the same firm — a point we raised about industry aliases a decade ago, and one a Kiplinger column echoed this past June. The ad litem believes they've run a wide, competitive canvass. Often, they've just collected several quotes from the same house. It gets worse where the competition is real. In the few jurisdictions that mandate ad litems, a dominant firm, and one in particular, can afford to bid below its own cost — not to serve the annuitant, but to win the deal and bleed the legitimate competitors who can't match a rate that loses money. It absorbs those losses on the strength of the notoriously poor deals it writes everywhere ad litems aren't required. Do that long enough and the smaller ethical firms simply leave those markets or leave the business altogether. Once the competition is gone, the "best available rate" is whatever the last firm standing cares to offer, and it’s always the big one with its support cast of companies — which nullifies the entire reason for appointing an ad litem to find the best deal in the first place. The reform meant to guarantee competition ends up quietly strangling it. If that pattern sounds familiar, it should: reforms in this industry have a long habit of ending up as a gift to its biggest players. So no — we don't champion the guardian ad litem. Not because independent advice is a bad idea; it's a fine one. It's because an advisor who canvasses a rigged market and doesn't know the finance well enough to see that it's rigged, isn't the safeguard everyone assumes. The protection that actually works costs nothing and predates all of this: education and a referral. An annuitant should first hear about factoring from the structured-settlement broker who built the annuity, and that broker should refer only to factoring professionals with a clean, ethical record — no court appointment, no cold calls, no counterfeit competition, just a trusted professional pointing the annuitant toward one we'd put our name behind.
Maryland’s Numbers: What 1,800 Transactions Falling to 6 Actually Tells Us - Bentzen Financial
September 17, 2026
Explore Maryland's structured settlement reforms and the reported drop in factoring petitions from 1,800 to six. Bentzen Financial shares key industry insights.
A Decade Later: What We Said in 2014, What John Oliver Said in 2026 - Bentzen Financial
August 20, 2026
Compare Bentzen Financial’s 2014 perspective on structured settlements with John Oliver’s 2026 commentary and what it means today.
Show More
SEE ALL ARTICLES